Target Date

Don’t get caught in the “volatility drag”

Polina Tsybrovska

April 4, 2024

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • In addition to looking at an investment’s results, it is important to consider its volatility and downside risk, especially given the impact large losses can have on investor behavior and the potential for long-term growth of wealth
  • As the magnitude of a loss increases, the subsequent gain required to recoup it grows exponentially
  • Metrics that assess an investment’s results relative to its risk, track its performance in both up and down markets, or illustrate its hypothetical growth over time can help investors compare alternatives

When it comes to markets and investments, it’s easy to focus on the upside. Lists of the top-performing sectors, funds and individual stocks feature prominently in financial media each year. It’s fun to focus on winners. Much less attention is paid to the equally important elements of volatility and downside risk.

 

Volatile periods can be unnerving for investors. They can result in emotional distress and may lead investors to succumb to decision-reversal risk, potentially abandoning their chosen investment program at precisely the wrong time — that is, at the point of maximum loss. But losses hurt mathematically as well as psychologically: They can have a serious negative effect on an investment’s long-term growth due to an effect known as “volatility drag.”

Target Date ProView

It’s easy to get a comparison with Morningstar® data on up to 4 target date series of your choice

CUSTOMIZE CLIENT-READY REPORTS

Consider a hypothetical $100,000 investment that loses 20%. To recoup the loss, the investment must gain 25%. Deepen the loss to 50%, and the gain to recoup the loss grows to 100%. The rebound gain necessary to recoup losses grows exponentially from there, as illustrated below.

Breaking even can be hard to do

From a starting point of 0%, which corresponds to the initial level of an investment, the animation depicts a blue line extending horizontally to the right. Simultaneously, a red curve extends downward and to the right in a concave manner. Hypothetical losses are denoted along this curve. The text “The pain from volatility starts small, with rebound gains nearly equal to the initial decline” is displayed above the graph. At the point indicating a 10% loss on the red curve, an arrow extends upward to meet the blue line, while increasing values appear and culminate at +11%, the percentage gain required to recoup that loss. The red curve continues extending down and to the right, and at the point indicating a 20% loss, an arrow extends upward to meet the blue line while increasing values appear and culminate at +25%, the gain required to recoup that loss. This pattern continues as the animation zooms out to illustrate the growing distance between the blue line and the red curve and the increasing difference between the loss and the corresponding gain required to break even. The text displayed above the graph changes to “But as losses grow, the rebound required grows exponentially.” The slope of the red curve continues to become steeper (more negative), so the distance each subsequent arrow must rise to meet the blue horizontal line also grows. This pattern is continued for eight additional hypothetical losses. For a 30% loss, a 43% gain is required to recoup the loss. For a 40% loss, a 67% gain is required. For a 50% loss, a 100% gain is required. For a 60% loss, a 150% gain is required. For a 70% loss, a 233% gain is required. For an 80% loss, a 400% gain is required. For a 90% loss, a 900% gain is required. For a 99% loss, a 9,900% gain is required.

Source: Capital Group. Not intended to portray an actual investment.

The outcome of this mathematical relationship is that even if an investment falls by 5% and subsequently rebounds by 5%, it ends with a loss of 0.25%.

 

Given its impact on the long-term growth of wealth and potential ramifications on behavioral elements, investors should be mindful of portfolio or investment volatility and downside resilience measures, not just returns data. They may find that downside resilience isn’t just nice to have — it’s practically a must-have for long-term wealth creation. 

 

When comparing investment alternatives, consider a few important metrics beyond absolute results:

  • Risk-adjusted returns, which typically incorporate both the performance achieved and the volatility experienced over a given time period. High Sharpe ratios* relative to comparable peers signify that an investment delivered attractive returns given its level of risk. 
  • Up- and downside capture ratios can be useful tools to help assess how an investment has performed in up and down markets. Specifically, the upside capture ratio is a measure of how well a portfolio performed when its index had positive returns, while the downside capture ratio indicates how it performed in periods of negative market returns. Generally, higher upside capture and lower downside capture is preferable.
  • Wealth generated in dollars — What’s most important for participants is how the metrics above translate to wealth creation in dollar terms. Tracking the growth of a hypothetical $100,000 investment over a long time frame helps illustrate how a given investment approach may deliver spendable wealth.

 

In the paper linked below, we take a closer look at how the thoughtful approach to risk mitigation taken in the American Funds Target Date Retirement Series® has delivered favorable outcomes for participants.

save_alt

DOWNLOAD PDF arrow_forward

Read important disclosures

polina-tsybrovska-2023-color-600x600

Polina Tsybrovska is a multi-asset product manager with 13 years of experience (as of 12/31/2023). She holds a bachelor’s degree in finance from the University of Illinois at Chicago.

Our latest insights

Did you miss the rally in stocks and bonds?
High-growth wealth managers focus on retirement plan participants
What can sports coaches teach us about retirement plans?
Is your defined contribution plan successful?
What to expect between Election Day and the inauguration

PRO

*Sharpe ratio uses standard deviation (a measure of volatility) and returns to determine the reward per unit of risk. The higher the ratio, the better the portfolio’s historical risk-adjusted performance.

Investments are not FDIC-insured, nor are they deposits of or guaranteed by a bank or any other entity, so they may lose value.
Investors should carefully consider investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. This and other important information is contained in the fund prospectuses and summary prospectuses, which can be obtained from a financial professional and should be read carefully before investing.
Although the target date portfolios are managed for investors on a projected retirement date time frame, the allocation strategy does not guarantee that investors' retirement goals will be met. Investment professionals manage the portfolio, moving it from a more growth-oriented strategy to a more income-oriented focus as the target date gets closer. The target date is the year that corresponds roughly to the year in which an investor is assumed to retire and begin taking withdrawals. Investment professionals continue to manage each portfolio for approximately 30 years after it reaches its target date.
Statements attributed to an individual represent the opinions of that individual as of the date published and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Capital Group or its affiliates. This information is intended to highlight issues and should not be considered advice, an endorsement or a recommendation.
All Capital Group trademarks mentioned are owned by The Capital Group Companies, Inc., an affiliated company or fund. All other company and product names mentioned are the property of their respective companies.
Use of this website is intended for U.S. residents only. Use of this website and materials is also subject to approval by your home office.
The Morningstar average expense ratios are based on fund statistics for each fund's prospectus available at the time of publication. The expense ratio is one aspect of plan fees and expenses.
Capital Client Group, Inc.
This content, developed by Capital Group, home of American Funds, should not be used as a primary basis for investment decisions and is not intended to serve as impartial investment or fiduciary advice.