Capital Ideas^TM

There is an old saying in the investment business: If you haven’t experienced a bankruptcy, then you’re probably not taking enough risk.

Bankruptcy should never be taken lightly, of course. But investing is a business of assessing risk and seeking reward. Mistakes are inevitable.

“It is very hard to consistently outsmart the market,” says equity portfolio manager Greg Wendt, who has been a professional investor for 35 years. “Even the most successful portfolio managers are right 55% of the time and wrong the other 45%. At Capital Group, we have a tradition of sharing our experiences with colleagues: to be supportive, empathetic and to remind them that if they keep working hard, they will get it right again.”

For equity portfolio manager Lisa Thompson, mistakes are the building blocks of future successes.

“You learn more from your mistakes than your successes,” says Thompson, who has 34 years of investment industry experience. “When you buy a stock and it works out well from the start, that feels great. But there is a chance that might be due to being in the right place at the right time. But I find that where I've learned a lot is when an idea didn’t work out or took very long to work out.”

In that spirit, five veteran portfolio managers share their investing mistakes and the subsequent lessons they learned.

1.   Beware of story stocks

Greg Wendt, equity portfolio manager

Earlier in my career, I invested in a cruise ship operator called American Classic Voyages based on a very powerful story. The company had roots in the Delta Queen Steamboat Company, which operated popular cruises up the Mississippi River. Billionaire financier Sam Zell, who saw an opportunity to disrupt the cruise industry, was the company chairman. American Classic Voyages planned to attain exclusive rights to cruise the Hawaiian Islands through a protectionist US maritime law.

I looked closely at the tourism dynamics for Hawaii and the cruise industry in general and recognised there would be strong demand for these trips. The company raised all the necessary capital, hired a dream team of managers, and began building the cruise liner at a Mississippi shipyard.

Now at the time, a cruise ship had not been built on US soil in more than 25 years, but the shipyard had extensive experience building military vessels. What could possibly go wrong?

Well, it turns out that recapturing industrial skills once they are lost is not so simple. The multibillion-dollar effort to build the ship failed, and for this and other reasons the company went bankrupt. It never occurred to me that you couldn’t find the talent to build a cruise ship in the US. The unfinished vessel ultimately was towed to Europe where it was eventually completed. Meanwhile, the investment thesis sank like a rock.

The lesson: Don’t assume a company can execute its business strategy without understanding how it will be done.

2. Avoid analysis paralysis

Lisa Thompson, equity portfolio manager 

Investing is a discipline that is part science and part art. To succeed, you need to be able to gather the data and do the math. But you also need to make judgment calls based on knowledge gained through experience.

I am by nature a contrarian investor. As such, I tend to avoid the crowd and get interested in an investment when others are selling. The great commodities super-cycle of the early 2000s driven by a rapidly growing China had more or less come to an end by 2014. After rising sharply from $10 a ton in 2003 to around $170 in April 2009, the price of iron ore plummeted to below $70 a ton by December 2014.

Shares of mining stocks also fell, pressured by the price drop. Against this backdrop, I began working with our analyst who covered mining stocks and grew interested in Brazilian iron ore producer Vale. Now, experienced investors in cyclical companies like Vale know it can be very difficult to call the bottom of a cycle. So during this period I was meeting regularly with the analyst to go over the numbers. Meanwhile the stock continued to drop.

At Capital, we have what I consider a competitive advantage in that our analysts often spend years, even decades, covering an industry. Through them, we have access to a vast amount of detailed knowledge. But at some point, I remember meeting with the mining analyst and asking, “We know so much about this company now, is more information going to tip the scales?”

I remember thinking that I already knew the discounted cash flows, the premiums, the fines, the global demand environment. One more data point would not help. I have to make the best decision I can with the information at hand. And these can be very hard decisions, but that is the job of a portfolio manager.

The lesson: Research is critical, but sometimes more information is too much. To invest successfully, you have to know when it is time to pull the trigger with the information you have.

3. Trust, but verify

Steve Watson, equity portfolio manager

At Capital, we place a lot of importance on knowing managements — meeting and having regular communication with them. Understanding executives as people can help us evaluate their business strategy and whether they are the right people to execute it. But it can potentially lead to a disinclination to ask, "I wonder if I'm being lied to?” Now the majority of executives we encounter are honest, well-intentioned people, but that doesn’t mean they’re always honest with us — or even themselves.

But occasionally even savvy investors can get caught up in a fraud. A few years after I began working in Capital’s Hong Kong office, I decided to invest in Sino-Forest, a Chinese company that owned and managed forest lands with the intent of eventually selling them to other investors.

Between 2003 and 2011, Sino’s shares, which were listed in Toronto, soared more than 500% based on company reports of strong profit growth. It turns out the company had fabricated numerous transactions, including some 450 in the first quarter of 2009.

In 2011, the company came under investigation by the Ontario Securities Commission. Trading of the company’s stock was suspended and by 2012 Sino had filed for bankruptcy. Ultimately the Ontario Securities Commission found that certain executives of the company “engaged in deceitful or dishonest conduct related to Sino-Forest’s standing timber assets and revenue that they knew constituted fraud”.

The lesson: Regard the financial statements and executives who manage them with a healthy dose of skepticism.

4. Resist your confirmation bias

Justin Toner, equity portfolio manager

I was hired by Capital Group on 4 September, 2001, to cover the aerospace and defense industries — a week before the September 11 terrorist attacks. I was assigned coverage of industries directly in the crosshairs of that catastrophe. Among the companies that I covered for more than 20 years was airplane manufacturer Boeing, in which I have invested in various amounts on and off over the years.

Boeing has lived through its share of crises — not only the September 11 attacks but more recently in 2019 with crashes of its 737 Max plane due to malfunctioning flight controls and in 2020 with the COVID pandemic. I was quite surprised by how rapidly Boeing’s stock reacted to the pandemic and shutdown of the global travel industry. Looking back with the benefit of hindsight, I can say that I underappreciated how bad things were going to get.

To be fair, I don't think anyone could have envisioned how bad it was going to get. But certainly, circumstances deteriorated rapidly and right on the heels of lingering difficulties from the 737 Max. That was a very difficult period for me as an analyst. I also held the shares as a portfolio manager in some portfolios.

After covering the industry for almost 20 years, you'd think that I would have seen the writing on the wall and been able to react quickly and decisively. But this job is very difficult, and just like all humans, investment managers can be victims of their own emotions and biases. We can be guilty of confirmation bias, the tendency to seek out information that confirms our pre-existing biases. That was a huge learning experience for me.

The lesson: Challenge your own point of view and be prepared to act quickly when circumstances change.

5. Know when to walk away

Martin Jacobs, Equity portfolio manager

Successful long-term investing is incredibly difficult, although it might seem incredibly simple: consistently identify great companies whose shares can generate superior returns over time.

But what I have also learned over my career is that great companies can stumble, so having a strong sell discipline and sticking to it can be just as important. This skill was highlighted in the book The Art of Execution: How the world’s best investors get it wrong and still make millions in the markets by Lee Freeman-Shor.

Freeman-Shor, a fund-of-funds manager, analysed seven years of data based on real investment outcomes for 45 of the world's top investors. One of the most interesting observations that came out of that study was the importance of weighting and conviction.

What he found was that it’s not how often you are right or wrong, but how much money you make when you're right and how much you lose when you're wrong. I can see across the portfolios I manage that these weighting and conviction decisions are so important.

The book identifies five different “tribes” of professional investors based on their behavior. One of the groups was called “assassins” because they were ruthless sellers. They were very focused on cutting their losses when a stock was down. Numerous studies in behavioural psychology have shown that investors find it about 10 times harder emotionally to realise a loss in real life than on paper. In other words, we all have an emotionally driven tendency to avoid cutting our losses and moving on.

So that ability to walk away from an investment when it's no longer working can be a very important discipline for successful investing. Long-term investors must learn to be willing to pivot when an investment thesis is broken. I have found this to be one of the hardest things to do as a portfolio manager.

The lesson: Knowing when to sell a stock and move on can be as important as knowing when to buy.